The Effect of Stabilization Exercise with and without Aquatic Exercise on Pain and Disability of Female Patients with Chronic Low Back Pain

Shadkampour, Shiva; Rahnam, Nader

The Effect of Stabilization Exercise with and without Aquatic Exercise on Pain and Disability of Female Patients with Chronic Low Back Pain

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Department of Physical Education and Sport Sciences, University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran

Abstract

Introduction: Low back pain is one of the most common musculoskeletal disorders. Due to complicated mechanisms of chronic low back pain, determining efficient and cost effective methods of treatment still is a challenge. The aim of this study was to compare the effects of stability exercise with and without aquatic exercise on chronic low back pain. Methods: twenty four Female with chronic low back pain due to disc degeneration or herniation recruited purposefully. They were matched and randomly assigned into stabilization exercise group and combined (stabilization plus aquatic exercise) group. Both groups received 6 weeks exercise intervention (three sessions per week). Pain (VAS) and functional disability (ODI) were assessed before and after interventions. Paired and independent t tests were used for analysis of data (P≤0.05). Results: The results showed significant reduction of VAS scores in stabilization (5.9±0.8 vs 3.8±1.1, P=0.00) and combined (6.2±0.6 vs 3.2±0.9, P=0.00) groups. Regarding disability, significant improvements was seen in stabilization (38.7±9 vs 26.3±9.4, P=0.00) and combined (39.4±8.3 vs 22.5±6.7, P=0.00) groups. Also significant differences was seen between groups, as combined group had around 12.9 % and 10.7% more reduction respectively in VAS (P=0.01) and ODI (P=0.02) scores. Conclusion: As combining aquatic exercises with core stability training could provide higher improvements in pain and functional disability of patients, we suggest aquatic exercise training should be added to rehabilitation programs of low back patients as a complementary modality.

Keywords

References

1. Cho HY, Kim EH Kim J. Effects of the CORE exercise program on pain and active range of motion in patients with chronic low back pain. J Phys Ther Sci. 2014; 26 (8): 1237- 1240.

2. Smith BE, Littlewood C, May S. An update of stabilisation exercises for low back pain: a systematic review with meta-analysis. BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders J. 2014; 15 (1): 416.

3. Rhee HS, Kim YH, Sung PS. A randomized controlled trial to determine the effect of spinal stabilization exercise intervention based on pain level and standing balance differences in patients with low back pain. Med Sci Monito Int Med J Experiment Clin Res. 2012; 18 (3): CR174.

4. Wang XQ, Zheng JJ, Yu ZW, Bi X, Lou SJ, Liu J, et al. A meta-analysis of core stability exercise versus general exercise for chronic low back pain. PloS One. 2012; 7 (12): e52082.

5. Ye C, Ren J, Zhan J, Wang C, Liu Z, Li F, et al. Comparison of lumbar spine stabilization exercise versus general exercise in young male patients with lumbar disc herniation after 1 year of follow-up. Int J Clin Experiment Med. 2015; 8 (6): 9869.

6. Van Tulder M, Becker A, Bekkering T, Breen A, Gil Del Real M, Hutchinson A, et al. Chapter 3 european guidelines for the management of acute nonspecific low back pain in primary care. Eur Spine J. 2006; 15: S169- S191.

7. Schroeder GD, Guyre CA, Vaccaro AR. The epidemiology and pathophysiology of lumbar disc herniations. Seminars in Spine Surgery. 2016.

8. Hodges PW, Moseley GL. Pain and motor control of the lumbopelvic region: effect and possible mechanisms. J Electrom Kinesiol. 2003; 13 (4): 361- 370.

9. Waller B, Lambeck J, Daly D. Therapeutic aquatic exercise in the treatment of low back pain: a systematic review. Clin Rehab. 2009; 23 (1): 3- 14.

10. Hall J, Swinkels L, Briddon J, McCabe CS. Does aquatic exercise relieve pain in adults with neurologic or musculoskeletal disease? A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Archives Phys Med Rehab. 2008; 89 (5): 873- 883.

11. Becker BE. Aquatic therapy: scientific foundations and clinical rehabilitation applications. PMR. 2009; 1 (9): 859- 872.

12. Kliziene I, Sipaviciene S, Klizas S, Imbrasiene S. Effects of core stability exercises on multifidus muscles in healthy women and women with chronic low-back pain. J Back Musculoskeletal Rehab. 2015; 28 (4): 841- 847.

13. Koumantakis GA, Watson PJ, Oldham JA. Trunk muscle stabilization training plus general exercise versus general exercise only: randomized controlled trial of patients with recurrent low back pain. Phys Ther. 2005; 85 (3): 209- 225.

14. Ferreira ML,Ferreira PH, Latimer J, Herbert RD, Hodges PW, Jennings MD, et al. Comparison of general exercise, motor control exercise and spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low back pain: a randomized trial. Pain J. 2007; 131 (1-2): 31- 37.

15. Ebrahimi H, Balouchi R, Eslami R, Shahrokhi M. Effect of 8-week core stabilization exercises on low back pain, abdominal and back muscle endurance in patients with chronic low back pain due to disc herniation. Phys Treat Specific Phys Ther J. 2014; 4 (1): 25- 32.

16. Moon HJ, Choi KH, Kim DH, Kim HJ, Cho YK, Lee KH, et al. Effect of lumbar stabilization and dynamic lumbar strengthening exercises in patients with chronic low back pain. An Rehab Med. 2013; 37 (1): 110- 117.

17. Hosseinifar M, Akbari M, Behtash H, Amiri M, Sarrafzadeh J. The effects of stabilization and McKenzie exercises on transverse abdominis and multifidus muscle thickness, pain, and disability: a randomized controlled trial in nonspecific chronic low back pain. J Phys Ther Sci. 2013; 25 (12): 1541- 1545.

18. Kumar T, Kumar S, Nezzamodin M, Sharma VP. Efficacy of core muscle strengthening exercise in chronic low back pain patients. J Back Musculoskeletal Rehab. 2015; 28 (4): 699- 707.

19. Nemčić T, Budišin V, Vrabec-Matković D, Grazio, S. Comparison of the effects of land-based and water-based therapeutic exercises on the range of motion and physical disability in patients with chronic low-back pain: single-blinded randomized study. Acta Clin Croatica. 2013; 52 (3): 321- 326.

20. Saggini R, Cancelli F, Di Bonaventoura V, Bellomo RG, Pezzatini A, Carniel R. Efficacy of two micro-gravitational protocols to treat chronic low back pain associated with discal lesions: a randomized controlled trial. Eur Medicophysica. 2004; 40 (4): 311- 316.

21. Yozbatiran N, Yildirim Y, Parlak B. Effects of fitness and aquafitness exercises on physical fitness in patients with chronic low back pain. Pain Clin. 2004; 16 (1): 35- 42.

22. Barker AL. Effectiveness of aquatic exercise for musculoskeletal conditions: a meta-analysis. Archives Phys Med Rehab. 2014; 95 (9): 1776- 1786.

23. Paungmali A, Henry LJ, Sitilertpisan P, Pirunsan U, Uthaikhup S. Improvements in tissue blood flow and lumbopelvic stability after lumbopelvic core stabilization training in patients with chronic non-specific low back pain. J Phys Ther Sci. 2016; 28 (2): 635- 640.

24. França FR, Burke TN, Hanada ES, Marques AP. Segmental stabilization and muscular strengthening in chronic low back pain: a comparative study. Clin J. 2010; 65 (10): 1013- 1017.

25. Panjabi MM. Clinical spinal instability and low back pain. J Electromyography Kinesiology. 2003; 13 (4): 371- 379.

26. Lizier DT, Perez MV, Sakata RK, Exercises for nonspecific low back pain treatment. Revista Brasil Anest. 2012; 62 (6): 842- 846.

27. Hodges PW. Core stability exercise in chronic low back pain. Orthopedic Clin North Am. 2003; 34 (2): 245- 254.

28. Macedo LG, Latimer J, Maher CG, Hodges Pw, McAuley JH, Nicholas MK, et al. Effect of motor control exercises versus graded activity in patients with chronic nonspecific low back pain: a randomized controlled trial. Phys Ther. 2012; 92 (3): 363- 377.

29. Hodges PW, Richardson CA. Altered trunk muscle recruitment in people with low back pain with upper limb movement at different speeds. Archives Phys Med Rehab. 1999; 80 (9): 1005- 1012.

30. Vasseljen O, Unsgaard-Tøndel M, Westad C, Mork PJ. Effect of core stability exercises on feed-forward activation of deep abdominal muscles in chronic low back pain: a randomized controlled trial. Spine J. 2012; 37 (13): 1101- 1108.

31. Vleeming A, Mooney V, Stoeckart R. Movement, stability & lumbopelvic pain: integration of research and therapy. Churchill Livingstone Elsevier Edinburgh. 2007.

32. O’Sullivan PB, Beales DJ. Changes in pelvic floor and diaphragm kinematics and respiratory patterns in subjects with sacroiliac joint pain following a motor learning intervention: a case series. Manual Ther. 2007; 12 (3): 209- 218.

33. Yue JJ, Timm JP, Panjabi MM, La Torre JJD. Clinical application of the Panjabi neutral zone hypothesis: the Stabilimax NZ posterior lumbar dynamic stabilization system. Neurosurgical Focus. 2007; 22 (1): 1- 3.

34. Panjabi MM. The stabilizing system of the spine. Part II. Neutral zone and instability hypothesis. J Spinal Disorders. 1992; 5: 390- 390.

35. O'Sullivan PB. Lumbar segmental ‘instability’: clinical presentation and specific stabilizing exercise management. Manual Ther. 2000; 5 (1): 2- 12.

36. Cairns MC, Foster NE, Wright C. Randomized controlled trial of specific spinal stabilization exercises and conventional physiotherapy for recurrent low back pain. Spine J. 2006; 31 (19): E670- E681.

37. Sarvestani H, Tabrizi H, Abbasi A, Rahmanpourmoghaddam J. The effect of eight weeks aquatic balance trainingand core stabilization training on dynamic balance in inactive elder males. Middle-East J Sci Res. 2012; 11 (3): 279- 286.

38. Melzack R, Katz J. The gate control theory: Reaching for the brain. Pain Psychol Perspectives. 2004; 1: 13- 34.

39. Granath AB, Hellgren MS, Gunnarsson RK. Water aerobics reduces sick leave due to low back pain during pregnancy. J Obstetric Gynecol Neonatal Nursing. 2006; 35 (4): 465- 471.

40. Dundar U, Solak O, Yigit I, Evcik D, Kavuncu V. Clinical effectiveness of aquatic exercise to treat chronic low back pain: a randomized controlled trial. Spine J. 2009; 34 (14): 1436- 1440.

41. Cuesta-Vargas AI, García-Romero JC, Arroyo-Morales M, Diego-Acosta AM, Daly DJ. Exercise, manual therapy, and education with or without high-intensity deep-water running for nonspecific chronic low back pain: a pragmatic randomized controlled trial. Am J Phys Med Rehab. 2011; 90 (7): 526- 538.

42. Cuesta-Vargas A, Adamas N, Salazar Ja, Belles A, Hazañas S, Arroyo-Morales M. Deep water running and general practice in primary care for non-specific low back pain versus general practice alone: randomized controlled trial. Clin Rheumatology. 2012; 31 (7): 1073- 1078.

43. O'sullivan PB, Phyty GDM, Twomey LT, Allison GT. Evaluation of specific stabilizing exercise in the treatment of chronic low back pain with radiologic diagnosis of spondylolysis or spondylolisthesis. Spine J. 1997; 22 (24): 2959- 2967.

44. Kumar S, Sharma VP, Negi MP. Efficacy of dynamic muscular stabilization techniques (DMST) over conventional techniques in rehabilitation of chronic low back pain. J Strength Cond Res. 2009; 23 (9): 2651- 2659.

45. Crisco J, Panjabi M. Euler stability of the human ligamentous lumbar spine. Part I: Theory. Clin Biomechanics. 1992; 7 (1): 19- 26.

46. Crisco Iii JJ, Panjabi MM. The intersegmental and multisegmental muscles of the lumbar spine: a biomechanical model comparing lateral stabilizing potential. Spine J. 1991; 16 (7): 793- 799.

47. Baena-Beato PA, Arroyo-Morales M, Delgado-Fernêndez M, Gatto-Cardia MC, Artero EG. Effects of different frequencies (2–3 days/week) of aquatic therapy program in adults with chronic low back pain. A non-randomized comparison trial. Pain Med J. 2013; 14 (1): 145- 158.

48. García RF, Sánchez LCS, Rodríguez MML, Granados GS. Effects of an exercise and relaxation aquatic program in patients with spondyloarthritis :a randomized trial. Med Clín. 2015; 145 (9): 380- 384.

49. Cuesta-Vargas AI, White M, González-Sánchez M, Kuisma R. The optimal frequency of aquatic physiotherapy for

individuals with chronic musculoskeletal pain: a randomised controlled trial. Disability Rehab. 2015; 37 (4): 311- 318.

50. Sjogren T, Long N, Story I, Smith J. Group hydrotherapy versus group land‐based treatment for chronic low back pain. Phys Res Int. 1997; 2 (4): 212- 222.

51. McIlveen B, Robertson VJ. A randomised controlled study of the outcome of hydrotherapy for subjects with low back or back and leg pain. Physiother. 1998; 84 (1): 17- 26.

52. Schrepfer R, Fritz J. A comparison of change in visual analogue pain rating of acute low back pain patients following deep water walking or deep water hanging. J Aquatic Phys Ther. 2000; 8: 25- 28.

53. Moayedi M, Davis KD. Theories of pain: from specificity to gate control. J Neurophysiol. 2013; 109 (1): 5- 12.